Standings after week 3

Berry
              Love      Hate
Week 2: (7/14)&(5/10)= 50%
Week 3: (11/18)&(6/11)=61% and 54.5%

Dr. Kirschner
Week 3:(10/16)&(6/10)=62.5% and 60%

My Week 3 Love/Hate updated w/ stats

Love

Michael Vick               291 pass yds, 3 TD, 30 rush yds TD

Joe Flacco                   262 pass yds, 3 TD

Carson Palmer             195 pass yds, TD, 2 int                       X

Pierre Thomas             6 rec. 91 total yds                              

Deangelo Williams      64 rush yds                                          X

Clinton Portis              1 rec. 58 total yds                               X

Anquan Boldin           8 rec. 142 yds 3 TD

Satana Moss                6 rec. 124 yds TD

Jeremy Maclin             4 rec. 83 yds 2 TD

Austin Collie               12. rec. 171 yds 2 TD

Bernard Berrian          2 rec. 11 yds                                        X

Jason Whitten             7 rec. 56 yds

Dustin Keller               6 rec. 98 yds 2 td

Marcedes Lewis          3 rec. 15 yds                                        X

 New England D         30 pts allowed, 1 sack 2 int                X

Arizona D                   23 pts allowed, 3 sacks, int    

Hate

Jay Cutler                    221 pass yds, TD, Int, 37 rush yds    

Matt Ryan                   228 pass yds 2 TD                              X

Alex Smith                  232 pass yds, TD, int

Vince Young               118 pass yds TD                    

Shonn Greene             36 rush yds

Ronnie Brown             2 rec. 53 total yds

Mike Sims-Walker      2 rec. 34 yds

Mike Wallace              3 rec 100 yds 2 TD                             X

Lee Evans                   5 rec. 54 yds                                        X

John Carlson               5 rec. 61 yds TD                                 X

Explanation for some: The Lee Evans hate is iffy but since the Pierre Thomas love is also iffy, I gave 50% and gave the X to one and not to the other.  The only other notable is Jay Cutler.  I didn't give him the X because he put up very similar statistics to Alex Smith who Mr. Berry also has and didn't put an X next to his name there.

Results

Love: 10/16

Hate: 6/10

Matthew Berry Week 3 Hate

Hate Verdict
Tom Brady 252 PASS YDS, 3 TD X
Brett Favre 201 pass yds, TD INT
Matt Ryan 228 YDS 2 TD X
Alex Smith 232 yds, TD, int
Thomas Jones 95 rush yds, TD, rec 1 yd X
Joseph Addai 29 RUSH YDS, 2 REC 10 YDS
manning/wayne not having top 5 weeks and not high on passing attack 325 AND 3 TDS X
Ryan Matthews DNP
Hakeem Nicks 7 REC 56 YDS X
Terrell Owens 4 REC 42 YDS
Robert Meachem 1 REC 5 YDS
Kellen Winslow 3 REC 24 YDS

Matthew Berry Week 3 Love

Love Verdict
Donovan Mcnabb 236 pass yds, 1 TD, int, 25 rush yds X..NEAR PUSH RANKED 17
Kyle Orton 476 YDS 1 TD, INT
Josh Freeman 184 PASS YDS, INT, 15 RUSH YDS X
Knowshon Moreno DNP
Matt Forte 29 rush yds, 2 rec 14 yds X
Shonn Green 36 rush yds X
Fred Taylor 16 RUSH YDS X
Santana Moss td 6 rec 124 yds TD
Hines Ward 3 REC 34 YDS TD
Malcom Floyd guaranteed td 6 REC 97 YDS TD
Louis Murphy 5 rec 119 yds
Mark Clayton 5 REC 85 YDS
Jeremy Maclin 4 REC 83 YDS 2 TD
Jason Whitten 7 REC 56 YDS
John Carlson 5 REC 61 YDS TD
Dustin Keller 6 rec 98 yds 2 td
Marcedes Lewis 3 REC 15 YDS X
Arizona D 23 pts allowed, 3 sacks, 1 int X
Kansas City D 10 PTS ALLOWED, INT, 5 SACKS FUM

My Week 3 Love/Hate

Based on Mr. Berry's Love/Hate, I have chosen players ranked very similarly to the ones he has chosen.  Here is my fantasy Love/Hate for the coming week.

Love

Michael Vick

Joe Flacco

Carson Palmer

Pierre Thomas

Deangelo Williams

Clinton Portis

Anquan Boldin

Satana Moss

Jeremy Maclin

Bernard Berrian

Jason Whitten

Dustin Keller

Marcedes Lewis

 New England D

Arizona D

Hate

Jay Cutler

Matt Ryan

Alex Smith

Vince Young

Shonn Greene

Ronnie Brown

Mike Sims-Walker

Mike Wallace

Lee Evans

John Carlson

Week 2 Love/Hate

Love Verdict Hate Verdict
Mike Vick 284 pass yds 2 td, 37 rush yds Jay Cutler 277 pass yds 3 td X
Kyle Orton 307 pass yds, 2 td David Garrard 173 pass yds, 1 td 4 int
Ahmad Bradshaw 89 rush yds X Jahvid Best 78 rush yds 2 td, 9 rec 154 yds td X
Cadilac Williams 51 rush yds 1 rec 8 yds X Tim Hightower 115 rush yds, td 2 rec 9 yds X
Brandon Jackson 29 rush yds 1 td, 1 rec 10 yds Felix Jones 7 rush yds, 2 rec 12 rec yds
Desean Jackson 4 rec 135 yds 1 td Randy Moss 2 rec 38 yds td X
Devin Aromashodu 0 stats X Terrell Owens 3 rec 57 yds
Pierre Garcon 1 rec 19 yds X Lee Evans 0 stats
Jabar Gaffney 2 rec 15 yds X Mike Sims-Walker 10 rec 105 yds td, fum X
Chris Cooley 3 rec 64 yds td Percy Harvin 5 rec 32 yds
Mohamed Massaquoi 1 rec 9 yds X
Todd Heap 4 rec 35 yds X
Kansas City Chiefs D 14 pts allowed, int, fum rec, 1 sack
San Diego D 13 pts allowed, 4 int 2 fum rec 2 sacks

Intro

Every week, ESPN fantasy "expert" Matthew Berry has a column called Love/Hate.  I happen to believe that Mr. Berry's opinion about NFL players shouldn't be the deciding factor in who to start for your fantasy team because I am just as, if not more educated than he is.  I have played Fantasy Football for the past 9 years and this season, I have tracked who Matthew Berry thinks will have good/bad weeks vs who I believe will have good/bad weeks from players ranked similarly near each other.  I am well qualified to challenge Mr. Berry based on my resume: Over the past 8 years, I have 4 first place finishes and 2 second place.  I started keeping track of the Love/Hate column in Week 2 of this season and started creating my own Love/Hate Column in Week 3.  By the end of the season, I hope to have a higher percentage of correct predictions then the "Talented" Mr. Roto has.